I don't keep it a secret that I think a well documentary far surpasses any other kind of film.
I got into documentaries primarily because of Brewdog, who is himself a budding documentarian. I can distinctly the first time he introduced me to this form of storytelling. It was the summer after my sophomore year in college and he had just received the movie Grizzly Man on Netflix. We watched it and I was transfixed. The movie (for those not in the know) is the story of Tim Treadwell, a bear lover who spent 15 summers in the Alaskan wilderness before ultimately being eaten by a bear. Treadwell was clearly a very disturbed person, which made this portrait of him extremely compelling. There were also a lot of strange choices by the film maker (Werner Herzog.) For example, the filmmaker has audio tape of Treadwell being eaten by the bear, but he doesn't play it. Rather, he shows the back of his own head as he listens to the tape. Afterward he tells Treadwell's sobbing former girlfriend "you must destroy this tape... if you do not it will be the white elephant in the room for the rest of your life." It is a huge mind fuck.
Since that experience I have had an insatiable appetite for documentaries. The reason I think that documentaries are so superior to other film is simple. They document real people and real events. Real people have so many more layers to them than could ever be fabricated and put into a Hollywood script. Real people have so many more subtle motivations and strange quirky things than an actor could ever imagine when playing a part. It is those layers and subtleties that make the human drama so compelling. The other thing to consider is that documentaries are made with so much more love and care than any feature film. Documentarians go through thousands of hours of footage and work for hours not only to make a cohesive story out of disjointed interviews and footage but also to find those moments of subtlety that give us perspective on who these real life characters are.
So in case you share my interest I will give you my list of the top five documentaries I enjoyed the most (although because I have a soft spot for Grizzly Man I have left it off the list.):
1) Crumb
About deranged psychedelic comic book artist R. Crumb this is one of the most critically acclaimed documentaries of all time. It goes through Crumb's impact on the American pop culture landscape by interviewing both fans and staunch critics of his work. While Crumb himself is crazy it is the portions in which his brothers are interviewed that prove most interesting to me. One brother sits on a bed of nails for the entire interview and explains that once every three days he must pass a long string through his body 9eating it then pulling it out of his rectum). The other brother still lives at home with his mother, never leaves the house and describes the reasons why he can't read contemporary literature, he prefers only 17th century French fiction. Needless to say, I find documentaries about crazy people the most enjoyable.
2) Helvetica
This is a story of the font-typeface Helvetica. Although it sounds like a rather dry subject it is actually pretty fascinating. They describe the origins of the font typeface, the various ways that fonts have evolved through the world of graphic design and the reason why Helvetica is the official font-typeface of corporate America (something like 90 large companies, including Energizer batteries and Target, have their corporate logo in Helvetica.) the really crazy thing is just how passionate people get about a simple font-typeface. Eventually, people are yelling and crying about Helvetica.
3) Word Wars.
The documentation of the 2000 (I think) national Scrabble tournament. being familiar with the national mock trial circuit let me truly appreciate this movie. There are crazy competitors who would be interesting to any watcher but the element that makes it so compelling to me is the scrabble community. There is a whole community of people that are huge celebrities to some but you and I wouldn't know them if we passed them on the street (just like in mock trial.) The best person in this movie is Marlon Hill, at the time the number 14 scrabble player in the country. Hill is an overweight pothead with dreadlocks from the ghettos of Baltimore. He constantly talks about how if he ever wins the scrabble championship he will "smoke a big fucking spliff right as I'm going to get my trophy." He also waxes on about how he hates German because "the language will take up the characteristics of the people. You got a greedy people the language gonna be greedy."
4) Mad Hot Ballroom
the story of Inner-city middle schoolers in New York who are taught ballroom dancing and are on a quest to win a city-wide competition. this movie is wonderful and the kids are just so darned cute.
5) Frontrunners
This follows the election for student body president in an extremely competitive private school. It is strange because although it is a high school election that I have no reason to care about it is great to watch. It serves as a microcosm for all politics. They discuss the reasons that certain people win that trace directly to the rational in the American people during national elections.